Criminal Court Fees Prevents Harms of Civil Debt: Ability to Pay, Collateral Consequences, Courts as Revenue Centers | North Carolina

By Rochelle Sparko, Peter Smith, Whitley Carpenter, Laura Webb and Heather Hunt

North Carolina law allows judges to order the conversion of financial obligations to civil judgments. Although doing this may protect justice-involved people from driver’s license suspensions, an extension of probation, and additional jail time, they often unknowingly open themselves to the seizure of their state tax refunds, loss of real estate or their equity in it, barriers to expunging their criminal record, and difficulty finding housing and employment. This report expounds on the relationship between using the civil legal system to enforce payment of criminal financial obligations. Researchers reviewed files from the North Carolina Administrative Office of the Courts (AOC) from January 2017 through December 2021 to determine the number of cases converted from criminal to civil judgments, their collection rates, and the impact of collecting criminal monetary obligations civilly. The report later provides recommendations for the AOC and practitioners to reduce harm to justice-involved people from court debt.

Durham, NC: The Center for Responsible Lending (CRL), Forward Justice, and The North Carolina Justice Center, 2023. 63p.