Gang Violence and Pacification in Ecuador: Comparing Trends in Guayaquil and Duran 2008-2024
By Mason Alexandra Rothenberger
Why has there been a dramatic increase in gang violence in Ecuador beginning in 2020? Cities like Guayaquil and Duran in the coastal region of Ecuador, as well as the border region that Ecuador shares with Colombia have experienced significant increases in criminal activity and with it a rise in criminal violence. I review four
hypotheses for why criminal violence has emerged and proliferated within Ecuador. Analysis of primary interviews with subject matter experts in Ecuador shows that the rise in violence resulted from the 2007 efforts to reintegrate gangs into society, which set the stage for fragmentation of gangs and the decision of these groups to use violence to maintain control. The national and regional consequences of this criminal activity persist. However, at present, criminal organizations’ domination of local regions results in fragmentation of state legitimacy, a split loyalty between the recognized state and a criminal organization. This double loyalty could result in a state being unable to effectively govern or create political will in the future. This thesis concludes with policy recommendations to stem criminal violence effectively. These recommendations are that states must invest in holistic solutions that target gang membership before it starts by investing in education, while it happens, by providing other viable legal options for social advancement, and after it has finished, through reintegration resources