Open Access Free Library
CRIME+CRIMINOLOGY.jpeg

CRIME

Violent-Non-Violent-Cyber-Global-Organized-Environmental-Policing-Crime Prevention-Victimization

Posts in Judicial Discretion
Borough Contrast: Prosecution and Court Outcomes Across New York City, 2021-2024,

By Joanna Weill, Michael Rempel, and Li Sian Goh April 2026

“Borough Contrast: Prosecution and Court Outcomes Across New York City, 2021-2024,” analyzes how criminal legal outcomes vary across the five boroughs during the post-pandemic period (pp. 1, 4).

Below are the key highlights and trends identified in the study:

1. Sharp Rise in Low-Level Arrests Citywide arrests surged by 62% from 2021 to 2024 (pp. 9, 14). This was driven largely by low-level offenses:

Fare Evasion: Increased more than elevenfold (900 to 10,125 arrests) (p. 4). Other Charges: Drug, trespass, and petit larceny arrests all approximately doubled citywide (pp. 4, 13). Borough Leaders: Brooklyn saw the largest increase in misdemeanor (+88%) and nonviolent felony (+73%) arrests, while the Bronx saw the highest spike in violent felony arrests (+49%) (pp. 4, 13).

2. Disparate Prosecution Decisions Whether a case is prosecuted depends heavily on the borough (pp. 6, 23):

The Bronx: Consistently held the highest “declination” rate (refusal to prosecute), declining 40% of misdemeanors and 25% of violent felonies in 2024 (pp. 5, 22-23). Manhattan: Saw a massive shift under DA Alvin Bragg, with misdemeanor declinations rising from 6% in 2021 to 31% in 2024 (pp. 5, 22). Other Boroughs: Queens, Brooklyn, and Staten Island declined significantly fewer cases, with Queens declining only 6% of
misdemeanors in 2024 (pp. 5, 22).

3. Pretrial Release & Bail
The study found significant differences in how judges handle cases at arraignment (pp. 6, 31): Bail Setting: Queens and Manhattan had the highest bail-setting rates for felonies (pp. 6, 31). In 2024, Manhattan judges set bail/remand in 53% of violent felony cases (p. 31). Ability to Pay: By 2024, bail payment rates at arraignment were exceptionally low (4–6% for misdemeanors), meaning a bail order almost always resulted in immediate incarceration (pp. 6, 36). Supervised Release: Judges citywide increasingly relied on supervised release over “Release on Recognizance” (ROR) for misdemeanors and nonviolent felonies (p. 33).

4. Convictions and Sentencing
Conviction Rates: Criminal convictions remain rare for misdemeanors (only 5% citywide in 2024) (pp. 7, 38). However, for indicted felonies, conviction rates were high, reaching 95% for violent felonies in Staten Island (pp. 7, 39). Prison Sentences: There was wide variability in prison time for felonies. In 2024, 34% of convicted felony cases in Manhattan resulted in state prison sentences, compared to only 12% in Queens (pp. 7, 42).
Demographic Disparity: Even after controlling for charge and history, Black and Hispanic individuals were significantly more likely than white individuals to be sentenced to prison

Evaluation of the Sentencing Council’s public order offences guidelines

By Caroline Kidd

The Sentencing Council for England and Wales was set up in 2010 and produces guidelines for use by all members of the judiciary when sentencing after conviction in criminal cases. The Council promotes a clear, fair, and consistent approach to sentencing by issuing sentencing guidelines and explanatory materials. It has a statutory duty to monitor these sentencing guidelines and to draw conclusions from the information obtained (s129 Coroners and Justice Act 2009). In October 2019, the Council published the public order offenses guidelines, which are a package of 7 guidelines covering 11 offenses. The 7 guidelines are for use in all courts and apply to all adult offenders (those aged 18 or over at the time of sentence). The guidelines came into force on 1 January 2020 and cover: • Riot (indictable only) • Violent disorder (triable-either-way) • Affray
(triable-either-way) • Threatening behavior – fear or provocation of violence/ Racially or religiously aggravated threatening behavior – fear or provocation of violence, hereafter referred to as the ‘Threatening behavior’ guideline (summary only, or triableeither-way for the racially or religiously aggravated offence) • Disorderly behaviour with intent to cause harassment, alarm or distress/ Racially or religiously aggravated disorderly behaviour with intent to cause harassment, alarm or distress, hereafter referred to as the
‘Disorderly behaviour with intent’ guideline (summary only, or triable-either-way for the racially or religiously aggravated offence) Disorderly behaviour/ Racially or religiously aggravated disorderly behaviour, hereafter referred to as the ‘Disorderly behaviour’ guideline (summary only) • Racial hatred offences/ Hatred against
persons on religious grounds or grounds of sexual orientation, hereafter referred to as the ‘Stirring up hatred offences’ guideline (triable-either-way)

These guidelines replaced the previous Magistrates’ Court Sentencing Guidelines (MCSG) which covered the offence of affray, summary offences relating to threatening behaviour, disorderly behaviour with intent and disorderly behaviour, and a brief reference to violent disorder offences which may be sentenced in magistrates’ courts. In addition, theThe Sentencing Council for England and Wales was set up in 2010 and produces guidelines for use by all members of the judiciary when sentencing after conviction in criminal cases. The Council promotes a clear, fair, and consistent approach to sentencing by issuing sentencing guidelines and explanatory materials. It has a statutory duty to monitor these sentencing guidelines and to draw conclusions from the information obtained (s129 Coroners and Justice Act 2009). In October 2019, the Council published the public order offences guidelines, which are a package of 7 guidelines covering 11 offences. The 7 guidelines are for use in all courts and apply to all adult offenders (those aged 18 or over at the time of sentence). The guidelines came into force on 1 January 2020 and cover: Riot (indictable only) Violent disorder (triable-either-way) Affray (triable-either-way) Threatening behaviour – fear or provocation of violence/ Racially or religiously aggravated threatening behaviour – fear or provocation of violence, hereafter referred to as the ‘Threatening behaviour’ guideline (summary only, or triableeither-way for the racially or religiously aggravated offence) • Disorderly behaviour with intent to cause harassment, alarm or distress/ Racially or religiously aggravated disorderly behaviour with intent to cause harassment, alarm or distress, hereafter referred to as the ‘Disorderly behaviour with intent’ guideline (summary only, or triable-either-way for the racially or religiously aggravated offence) • Disorderly behaviour/ Racially or religiously aggravated disorderly behaviour, hereafter referred to as the ‘Disorderly behaviour’ guideline (summary only) • Racial hatred offences/ Hatred against persons on religious grounds or grounds of sexual orientation, hereafter referred to as the ‘Stirring up hatred offences’ guideline (triable-either-way)

These guidelines replaced the previous Magistrates’ Court Sentencing Guidelines (MCSG) which covered the offence of affray, summary offences relating to threatening behaviour, disorderly behaviour with intent and disorderly behaviour, and a brief reference to violent disorder offences which may be sentenced in magistrates’ courts. In addition, the the package introduced new guidelines for riot and offences relating to stirring up racial or religious hatred and hatred based on sexual orientation. The aims of the guidelines are to ensure that all sentences are proportionate to the offence committed and in relation to other offences, and additionally to promote a consistent approach to sentencing