A Psychological and Educational Survey of 1916 Prisoners in the Western Penitentiary of Pennsylvania
By William T. Root, Jr.. With A Report on the Italian Convict, by Giovanni Giardini. . Modernized with a new Introduction by Graeme R. Newman.
Originally published in 1927, this pioneering study offers a remarkable examination of the psychological, educational, and social characteristics of 1,916 prisoners in Pennsylvania's Western Penitentiary. Based on extensive individual interviews, intelligence testing, psychiatric assessments, and institutional records collected between 1924 and 1926, William T. Root, Jr. investigates the complex relationship between criminal behavior, intelligence, education, poverty, family circumstances, and social environment.
Challenging the prevailing emphasis on punishment and vengeance, Root argues that criminal conduct must be understood through its underlying causes. His findings raise enduring questions about personal responsibility, social inequality, rehabilitation, and the capacity of prisons to reform rather than merely confine offenders.
The volume also includes Giovanni Giardini's revealing investigation of Italian immigrant prisoners, examining the influence of cultural background, immigration, and changing social conditions on patterns of offending.
Although rooted in the psychological theories and classifications of the 1920s, some now discredited, this work remains an important historical contribution to criminology, correctional psychology, and the development of evidence-based prison reform.
This Read-Me.Org Modernized-Classic edition presents a carefully condensed and modernized text, replacing extensive statistical tables with accessible summaries while retaining selected original graphs. A new Introduction by Graeme R. Newman places the study in its historical and intellectual context, critically examines its assumptions, and explains its continuing relevance. Review and discussion questions make the volume particularly useful for students, researchers, and readers interested in the history of criminal justice.
A compelling historical document that asks a question as urgent today as it was a century ago: Should society seek to understand and reform those who commit crimes, or simply punish them?
Read-Me.Org Inc. New York-Philadelphia-Australia. 2026. p.105.